Sleepio vs CBT-i Coach: which one fits you?
Sleepio vs CBT-i Coach is a choice between a guided program and a free toolbox. Sleepio is a six-week CBT-I program that teaches you step by step; in the US its prescription form, SleepioRx, is reached through a clinician or a health plan. CBT-i Coach is a free app from the US Department of Veterans Affairs that is built to sit alongside a therapist. If you have no therapist and want a plan, the free VA sibling Insomnia Coach is the closer free match for Sleepio. Start with the numbers: our free 2-minute sleep quiz shows your minutes awake in bed and a starting window either tool will ask for.
Below: a side-by-side table, how each one is used, who can get them, what the evidence covers, how to choose, and what to do if one does not work. This is not medical advice.
Sleepio vs CBT-i Coach side by side
| Sleepio (SleepioRx in the US) | CBT-i Coach | |
|---|---|---|
| Maker | Big Health | US Department of Veterans Affairs and partners |
| Shape | A guided program of about six weeks with weekly sessions and a daily diary | A toolbox: diary, sleep window, reminders, lessons, relaxation |
| Built for | Adults with chronic insomnia working alone | People doing CBT-I with a clinician, or who know the steps |
| Cost | Depends on plan or health service; no public US list price found | Free |
| Access (US) | FDA-cleared prescription product for adults 18+; a clinician orders it | Download from the app stores; open to anyone |
| Human support | None built in, apart from your prescriber | Your clinician, if you have one |
| Evidence | NICE recommended Sleepio in 2022; FDA clearance in 2024 | Small pilot studies; designed to support therapy |
How each one is used
Sleepio tells you what to do. You take a sleep test, then work through weekly sessions while a diary sets your time in bed. It sets the window and adjusts it, so you do not need to know the method. Users get access for a year from when they start.
CBT-i Coach gives you tools and assumes you or your therapist will use them. The therapist sets the window and reviews the diary; the app holds the diary, reminders and relaxation exercises. It can be used alone, but you then set and adjust the window yourself, which is the hardest part. The steps are in sleep restriction for insomnia.
Who can get which
CBT-i Coach is a download. Sleepio is not, in the US: SleepioRx needs a clinician's order, and what you pay depends on your plan, which Big Health lists across Medicare Advantage, commercial and Medicaid plans. Ask your doctor and your plan's member services. In England NICE recommended Sleepio in 2022, but local access has varied. If you cannot get Sleepio, the free VA program Insomnia Coach is the nearest free route: CBT-i Coach vs Insomnia Coach explains the two VA apps.
What the evidence covers
Both rest on CBT-I, the first-line treatment in the 2016 American College of Physicians and 2021 AASM guidelines. Sleepio has more published support as a stand-alone program, including the NICE appraisal, and FDA clearance for SleepioRx as an adjunct to usual care. CBT-i Coach was designed to support therapy, and public evidence is mainly small pilot work. That does not make the free tool useless; it means its job is to hold your diary while a person guides you. See does CBT really work for insomnia?
How to choose
| If this is you | Pick | Why |
|---|---|---|
| No therapist, want a plan, can get a prescription or coverage | Sleepio | It sets and adjusts the window for you |
| No therapist, no coverage, no money | Insomnia Coach (free), not CBT-i Coach | Free and built to work alone |
| You see a CBT-I therapist | CBT-i Coach | It carries the diary your therapist uses |
| You know the method and want only a diary | CBT-i Coach or a paper diary | You do not need a program |
| You quit programs without a person | Add a therapist or group | See finding a CBT-I therapist |
A week-by-week plan whichever you choose
- Week 0: pick one wake time you can hold seven days a week. Set the alarm.
- Week 1: fill in the diary within ten minutes of waking. Change nothing else.
- Weeks 2 to 3: follow the window. Stay up until it opens; if awake in bed about 20 minutes, get up and return when sleepy (stimulus control).
- Weeks 4 to 6: let the window grow when efficiency (time asleep divided by time in bed) is over about 85%, and trim it if under 80%.
- Week 6: judge on the diary: time to fall asleep, long wakings, efficiency.
Safety: when to bring in a clinician first
- Bipolar disorder or a history of mania.
- Seizure disorders.
- Signs of sleep apnea: loud snoring, gasping, heavy sleepiness despite long nights.
- Safety-critical work or driving.
- Long-term sleeping pills you want to stop; see CBT-I vs medication.
If you want to compare more options
Other formats, prices and what each is good at are in the best online CBT programs for insomnia, Sleepio vs Somryst and CBT for insomnia apps. The cost picture across all of them is in what CBT for insomnia costs. Whether Sleepio specifically is worth chasing is covered in is Sleepio worth it?
What week 2 feels like with each tool
The hard part is the same whichever you pick: a shorter window and a sleepy week. With a guided program like Sleepio, the app sets the new bedtime and explains why, so you follow it. With CBT-i Coach used alone, you calculate the window yourself from your diary, which is where people go wrong: they set it too long to feel comfortable, or too short to be safe. A common starting rule in CBT-I is to set time in bed to your average sleep time over the diary week, never below about five hours, then adjust weekly. If doing that math sounds unpleasant, that is a real reason to choose a guided program or a therapist.
Mistakes to avoid
- Choosing by polish. A smooth design helps you open the app, but the result comes from the diary and the fixed wake time.
- Changing the window every day. Adjust once a week on the average, not on last night.
- Counting the paid price as the only cost. Time matters too: a free toolbox you will not use costs more than a covered program you finish.
- Skipping the doctor when a flag applies. Apnea, bipolar disorder and seizure disorders change what is safe.
Questions to ask before you commit
- Who sets my window, the app or me?
- Is a person reachable if the program stalls?
- What will I pay, and when does billing start?
- Does it screen for the safety flags above?
- What will I look at in week 6 to know it worked?
If you can answer all five for a tool, it is a reasonable choice. If you cannot answer two or more, keep looking or start with the free route above.
Where each tool wins
If you want the lowest cost and can work from a plain diary, CBT-i Coach or a paper log costs nothing and holds everything you need. If you want a teacher, Sleepio's sessions explain why each step exists, which helps people who comply better when they understand the reason. If you want a person, neither replaces a therapist. A mixed plan is common: use a free diary tool for the first two weeks to see your real numbers, then decide whether you need more. Those first two weeks of numbers are useful whichever route you take, and they cost nothing.
One more point on evidence. A tool that has a trial behind it is not automatically better for you than one without, because the trial tells you about the average user, and you are one person. What predicts success for nearly everyone is the same: a steady wake time, a diary kept every morning, and the patience to stay with a short window for two or three weeks. Choose the tool that makes those three things easiest for you to keep doing.
Frequently asked questions
Is Sleepio better than CBT-i Coach?
For working alone, Sleepio is the more complete program. CBT-i Coach is not built to be a stand-alone program. They solve different problems.
Is CBT-i Coach free?
Yes, free to download and open to anyone. Check the store listing for changes.
Can I get Sleepio without a doctor in the US?
The FDA-cleared SleepioRx is ordered by a licensed clinician. Ask your doctor or plan.
Which is better for beginners?
A guided program. If Sleepio is not available, Insomnia Coach is the free guided option.
Can I use both?
Pick one diary and one window. Two will disagree and you will not know which to follow.
How long before I know it works?
Judge at week 4 to 6 on your diary, not on one bad night.
Start with the free part
Before you choose, take the free sleep quiz for your starting window. More on all sleep guides.
Sources: Big Health, SleepioRx FDA clearance and health-plan pages; NICE guidance on Sleepio, May 2022 (as reported by trade press); US Department of Veterans Affairs, National Center for PTSD: CBT-i Coach and Insomnia Coach pages; Edinger JD et al., AASM guideline, J Clin Sleep Med, 2021; Qaseem A et al., ACP guideline, Annals of Internal Medicine, 2016. Prices and access change; confirm with your plan. Not medical advice.