CBT for insomnia workbook: 5 compared, and how to use one
A good CBT for insomnia workbook does five jobs: it has you keep a sleep diary, it works out a sleep window from your own numbers, it teaches stimulus control (using the bed only for sleep), it gives you a way to handle sleep-related worry, and it plans for setbacks. Of the books below, Quiet Your Mind and Get to Sleep is the one most written for a reader working alone, and Overcoming Insomnia by Edinger and Carney is built to be used with a therapist.
If you'd rather start with something shorter than a book, our free 2-minute sleep quiz gives you a starting sleep window from your own answers. Below: what a workbook must contain, five compared in one table, how to pick, a 6-week schedule for working through any of them, why people stall, and what to do if a book alone isn't enough.
What a CBT for insomnia workbook has to contain
CBT for insomnia (CBT-I) is the first treatment doctors recommend for long-lasting insomnia. The American College of Physicians says so in its 2016 guideline, and the American Academy of Sleep Medicine (AASM) backs a multi-part behavioral program in its 2021 guideline. "Multi-part" matters. A book that is only tips on bedrooms and caffeine is a sleep hygiene book, not a CBT-I workbook. Use this list to check any title before you buy it.
| Part | What you should see in the book | Missing means |
|---|---|---|
| Sleep diary | A form to fill in each morning: bedtime, minutes to fall asleep, time awake in the night, wake time, time out of bed | It can't be personal; you're guessing |
| Sleep window (sleep restriction) | A worked method to set your time in bed from the diary, and rules to widen it | The strongest single part is gone |
| Stimulus control | Bed for sleep only, go when sleepy, get up if awake about 20 minutes, same wake time | It's tips, not therapy |
| Thought work | Ways to question beliefs like "I'll be ruined tomorrow if I don't sleep" | Worry keeps feeding the habit |
| Relaxation and wind-down | A taught method (muscle relaxation, slow breathing) and an evening routine | Fine, but a smaller loss |
| Setback plan | What to do after a bad week | Most people quit at the first bad week |
| Safety notes | Who should not restrict sleep alone, and when to see a doctor | A reason to put it back on the shelf |
The sleep diary and the sleep window do most of the work. Our guide to all seven CBT-I techniques explains each part in detail, and sleep restriction for insomnia shows the window step by step.
5 CBT for insomnia workbooks compared
| Book | Authors, year | Format | Best for | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Quiet Your Mind and Get to Sleep | Colleen Carney and Rachel Manber, New Harbinger, 2009 | Self-help workbook with exercises and diaries | Insomnia that comes with low mood, anxiety or chronic pain | Written in 2009; check for a newer edition |
| The Insomnia Workbook | Stephanie Silberman, New Harbinger, 2009 | Self-help workbook, many worksheets | People who like to fill in forms and go in order | Takes real effort; a reviewer's warning, not a flaw |
| Overcoming Insomnia: A Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy Approach, Workbook | Jack Edinger and Colleen Carney, Oxford University Press (Treatments That Work), 2nd edition 2015 | Patient workbook that goes with a therapist's guide | Doing CBT-I with a clinician, or a reader who wants the clinical version | Designed to be used with a therapist; terse and clinical |
| Say Good Night to Insomnia | Gregg Jacobs, Henry Holt, 1998 | Six-week program in book form | People who want a clear 6-week structure | The oldest of the five; newer research is not in it |
| Hello Sleep | Jade Wu, 2023 | Readable guide, lighter on forms | Readers who want the current science in plain words first | Less of a fill-in workbook than the others |
We haven't compared these books in a trial, and nobody has, so the table says what each one is, not which one "works best". Prices change; check the current price and whether your library has a copy before buying. Most libraries do.
How to pick the right CBT for insomnia workbook
- If worry, low mood or pain keeps you up, start with Quiet Your Mind and Get to Sleep. It's the one of the five written around that mix.
- If you want worksheets to fill in and a clear order to follow, The Insomnia Workbook is built that way.
- If you're seeing a therapist or plan to, ask them first. Many use the Edinger and Carney workbook, and then you'd want the same one.
- If you need a plain 6-week shape and don't mind an older book, Say Good Night to Insomnia gives you one.
- If you read slowly and quit forms, begin with Hello Sleep and pair it with a free sleep diary.
Whichever you pick, check it has the sleep diary and a worked sleep window. If it doesn't tell you how to set time in bed, it's missing the strongest part.
The free parts you can use today
You don't need to buy anything to start the two parts that matter most.
- The Consensus Sleep Diary. Carney and colleagues published it in the journal Sleep in 2012 as a standard diary, free to use. Fill it in within an hour of waking, for 7 to 14 days.
- The five numbers. From your diary, work out: average time in bed, average time asleep, minutes to fall asleep, minutes awake in the night, and wake time. These are what every workbook is trying to move.
- A starting sleep window. Take your average sleep time, add 30 minutes, and never go below 5.5 hours. Keep your wake time fixed and move only your bedtime. The workbooks give the full rules; this is the starting point.
- The VA's free apps. CBT-i Coach and Insomnia Coach, made by the US Department of Veterans Affairs, are free and open to anyone. See CBT for insomnia apps compared.
A 6-week schedule for any CBT for insomnia workbook
Most workbooks run 4 to 8 weeks. If yours doesn't set a pace, use this one so you don't read for a month and change nothing.
| Week | Read and do |
|---|---|
| 1 | Read the intro and the diary chapter. Fill in the diary every morning. Change nothing yet except one wake time. |
| 2 | Work out your sleep window from week 1. Start it. Add stimulus control: bed for sleep only, up if awake about 20 minutes. |
| 3 | Keep the window. Expect to feel sleepier in the day; this is normal at this stage. Read the thought-work chapter and use one exercise a night. |
| 4 | Check the diary. If you slept in 85% or more of your time in bed for the week, move bedtime 15 minutes earlier. If under 80%, hold. |
| 5 | Add the wind-down and relaxation chapters. Keep adjusting the window by 15 minutes a week. |
| 6 | Write your setback plan: what you'll do after two bad nights. Keep the diary up for one more week. |
The 85% and 80% cut-offs are common in clinical CBT-I protocols, but your book may use slightly different ones. Follow your book if it differs.
Why people stall with a workbook
- They read it and don't fill in the diary. Without your own numbers, the sleep window is a guess.
- They skip the sleep window because it feels harsh. It's the part with the best evidence, and it's short-term.
- They change the wake time on weekends. A fixed wake time is what makes the rest work.
- They quit in week 2, when they feel sleepier before sleep improves.
- They try all the chapters at once. Add one part a week.
- They have another problem. Snoring and gasping, restless legs or night sweats need a doctor, and no workbook fixes them.
Workbook, app or therapist?
| Option | Cost to know about | Best for | Limit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Workbook | One book; free from many libraries | Self-driven readers who'll fill in forms | No one checks your diary |
| Free apps (VA) | Free | People who prefer a phone to a book | No coach; easy to drift |
| Digital CBT-I program | NICE in the UK puts Sleepio at £45 per person for the NHS; US access is through employers, plans or prescription and varies | People who want a guided 6 to 9 weeks | Cover and cost differ by plan |
| Therapist | A US study of CBT-I providers found an average first session near $261; NICE modelled face-to-face CBT-I at about £492 a person in the UK | Complex cases, other health problems, no progress alone | Few certified clinicians; many don't take insurance |
Our guide to what CBT for insomnia costs goes through these in more detail.
Where our sleep reset fits
We should be clear about what we are. Our sleep reset is a 6-week habit plan, not CBT-I treatment and not medical care. It uses habits close to the ones in these workbooks: a sleep window, a wind-down and "bed = sleep". It costs $9.99 for the first week, then $14.99 a month or $69 a year, and you can cancel in one tap. If you want a book's depth, buy the book. If you want a daily plan to follow without forms, see the sleep reset plan, or start with the free quiz.
When to see a doctor
See a doctor before doing sleep restriction alone if you have epilepsy, bipolar disorder, a job that needs sharp alertness at odd hours (driving, machinery), or if you've had a fall or near miss from drowsiness. See one for loud snoring with gasping, a pounding heart at night, restless legs, low mood that doesn't lift, or insomnia that's lasted over three months and isn't moving after 6 to 8 weeks of honest effort. Ask for CBT-I by name.
Frequently asked questions
Do CBT for insomnia workbooks work?
The method works; trials of CBT-I, including self-help and online versions, show gains in how fast people fall asleep and how long they lie awake. A book works only if you do the diary and the sleep window, not just read.
What is the best CBT for insomnia workbook?
There's no head-to-head trial. Quiet Your Mind and Get to Sleep is a good start for most people working alone, and the Edinger and Carney workbook suits use with a therapist.
Is there a free CBT for insomnia workbook?
Not a full free book that we can point to, but you can use the free Consensus Sleep Diary, the VA's free apps and your library's copies of the paid books.
How long does it take to work through a workbook?
Most are 4 to 8 weeks. Plan on 6, and expect the first two weeks to feel harder, not easier.
Can I do CBT-I from a book without a therapist?
For many adults, yes. Skip sleep restriction alone and talk to a doctor first if you have bipolar disorder, epilepsy, or work that needs alertness at odd hours.
Start this week
Print or copy a sleep diary tonight, fill it in for a week, and then pick the book that fits. If you'd like a window worked out for you in two minutes, take the free sleep quiz. All our guides are on the sleep guides page.
Sources: Qaseem A et al., Management of chronic insomnia disorder in adults: a clinical practice guideline from the American College of Physicians, Annals of Internal Medicine, 2016. Edinger JD et al., Behavioral and psychological treatments for chronic insomnia disorder in adults: an AASM clinical practice guideline, Journal of Clinical Sleep Medicine, 2021. Carney CE et al., The Consensus Sleep Diary: standardizing prospective sleep self-monitoring, Sleep, 2012. NICE, Sleepio to treat insomnia and insomnia symptoms (HTG624, formerly MTG70): cost of £45 per person and face-to-face CBT-I modelled at £492 (adjusted £542). Henry Ford Health, Behavioral insomnia treatment accessibility in the US: a real-world assessment of cost, location and availability (meeting abstract). Publisher details of the books are as listed on their publishers' and retailers' pages.