by Strong Mornings See our plans

Why are my Kegels not working? Seven reasons and what to check

When Kegels don't work, the cause is usually one of seven things, and the most common is that the squeeze itself is wrong. In a well-known study, only about half of women did an ideal Kegel after a short spoken explanation, and a quarter did one that could make leaks worse. The others are: the muscles are too tight, not enough time has passed, the routine never gets harder, the squeeze isn't used when leaks happen, the leak is the urge kind, or menopause has changed the tissue. This guide takes them in the order you can check them, with the numbers from the trials and the guidelines.

It is training and habits, not medical care. If you have pain, bleeding, a bulge, or trouble passing urine, see a doctor or a pelvic floor physical therapist first.

First, how long have you really tried?

Most "not working" is "not long enough". Cleveland Clinic puts the first change at about 6 to 8 weeks of daily training. The UK's NICE guideline asks for a supervised programme of at least 3 months, with at least 8 squeezes three times a day, before judging it. In the Cochrane review of 31 trials and 1,817 women, women with leaks on a cough, sneeze, laugh or lift who trained were about 8 times more likely to report being cured than women who did nothing: 56% versus 6%. Those trials ran for weeks to months, most often around 3 months, and most were supervised.

So the fair question is not "has it worked in two weeks?" but "have I done a proper programme, most days, for 8 to 12 weeks?" If yes, read on. If not, the week-by-week timeline is in how long Kegels take to work.

The seven reasons, and how to tell which is yours

ReasonWhat you tend to noticeFirst thing to check
1. The squeeze is wrongBelly bulges, you hold your breath, you feel pressure downwardHand on belly, mirror, counting out loud
2. The muscles are too tightPain with sex, slow or stop-start stream, constipation, can't feel a let-goStop squeezing for 2 weeks, practise letting go
3. It hasn't been long enoughUnder 6 to 8 weeks of daily workCount your weeks; keep a hold and leak log
4. The routine never gets harderSame easy 10 squeezes for monthsAdd a second to the hold or a squeeze to the set
5. You never use it when it countsStrong lying down, still leak on a sneeze or a liftSqueeze just before the cough, lift or stand
6. It's the urge kind of leakA sudden strong need to go, leaks on the way to the toiletA 3-day bladder diary
7. Menopause or surgery changed the tissueDryness, soreness, heaviness, a squeeze that feels differentTalk to a doctor; keep training

1. The squeeze is wrong (the biggest one)

You cannot see these muscles, so it is easy to train the wrong thing for months. In a 1991 study of women with leaks, given brief standard instructions, 49% did an ideal Kegel and 25% did one that could promote leaking. On ultrasound, another research group found that 43% of women with leaks or prolapse pushed the pelvic floor down when asked to lift it. Age, number of births and weight did not predict who got it right. Clear instruction and feedback did.

Signs the squeeze is wrong: your belly pushes out or goes hard, you hold your breath, your bottom or thighs do the work, or it feels like bearing down. Three quick checks:

The full step-by-step, and all seven home checks, are in how to do Kegels correctly and how to know if you are doing Kegels correctly.

2. Your pelvic floor is too tight, not too weak

A pelvic floor can be both tight and weak. When the muscles are already partly clenched all the time, there is little room left to squeeze, so a Kegel feels like nothing, and more squeezing can flare symptoms. Clinics that treat pelvic pain say this often. Signs that point this way: you can't feel a clear let-go either; pain with sex, tampons or a smear test; a slow or stop-start stream or a feeling you haven't emptied; straining with bowel movements; aching in the pelvis, hips, low back or tailbone; a habit of bracing your belly or clenching your jaw when stressed.

What to do: stop Kegels for two weeks and practise letting go. Belly breathing, where the pelvic floor drops gently as you breathe in, is the start. See tight pelvic floor symptoms to tell tight from weak and how to relax your pelvic floor muscles. If you have pain or trouble starting to pass urine, see a pelvic floor physical therapist before starting a squeezing programme.

3. It hasn't been long enough, or you stopped

In the first weeks of any strength training, most of the gain is in the nervous system: your brain learns which muscle to fire. That is real progress, but it doesn't show as fewer leaks yet, because leaks happen when the pressure in your belly beats the closing force of the pelvic floor, and closing force takes weeks to build.

This is also where most women stop. A large US study of women after menopause found only about half were still training as advised at 3 months, and fewer than 4 in 10 at a year. In trials, the top reason for stopping was simply forgetting; others were boredom and no feedback while results came slowly. Pick a fixed cue (after brushing your teeth, before the kettle boils) and write down your hold time on day 1.

4. The routine never gets harder

Muscles grow when they are asked to do a little more than last time. Trial programmes use close-to-full-effort squeezes, longer holds as the weeks pass, quick squeezes as well as slow ones, and a full let-go between each. Ten gentle squeezes in the car every day for a year is a habit, not training.

The numbers to aim for are in how many Kegels a day: NICE asks for at least 8 squeezes, at least 3 times a day, for at least 3 months. Add one second to your hold or one squeeze to your set every week or two. And do not overdo it: yes, you can do too many, and a tired muscle holds less, not more.

5. You never use the squeeze at the moment that counts

Leaks happen when you sneeze, laugh, lift or stand up. Strength you only use lying down won't help in those moments until you practise the squeeze there. In a 1998 study of selected older women with mild to moderate leaks, learning to squeeze just before and during a cough cut leakage on a medium cough by an average of 98% after one week. Their strength hadn't changed: the gain was timing, a skill. It is called the Knack, and it is the fastest win most women get. The steps are in leaking urine when sneezing or coughing.

6. It's the urge kind of leak

Kegels are the first treatment for stress leaks (cough, sneeze, laugh, lift). If your leaks come with a sudden strong need to go, or on the way to the toilet, you may have an urge leak, where the first treatment is bladder training, not more squeezes. NICE asks for a trial of at least 6 weeks. In a 1991 JAMA study, 123 women aged 55 and over did a six-week bladder training programme and their leaks fell by 57% on average, compared with women who didn't train. Many women over 40 have both, called mixed leaks, and NICE's advice is to treat the part that bothers you most first.

A 3-day bladder diary tells you which you have. See urge versus stress incontinence and the bladder training schedule.

7. Menopause or surgery changed the tissue

Falling estrogen around menopause thins and dries the tissue of the vagina, urethra and bladder, and many women link the start of their leaks to their last periods. The muscles can still be trained, but the feeling of a squeeze can change, and dryness or soreness can make it harder to tell what you are doing. A doctor can talk with you about vaginal estrogen, which NICE recommends for women past menopause with an overactive bladder and vaginal atrophy. After a hysterectomy, prolapse repair or other pelvic surgery, the muscles and nerves can take time to recover; follow your surgeon's advice on when to restart.

See bladder leakage and menopause, and if a squeeze you used to feel has faded, why you can't do Kegels anymore.

A 10-minute check you can do tonight

  1. Lie down, knees bent, one hand on your belly. Breathe in and let the belly rise. Breathe out and gently lift, as if stopping wind and holding back urine. If the hand moves out, you are pushing: go back to reason 1.
  2. Time your hold while you count out loud. Write the number down. Your goal over weeks is to rise from 3 seconds towards 8 to 10.
  3. Notice the let-go. If you can't feel the muscles drop and soften after the squeeze, or you have pain, go to reason 2 before squeezing again.
  4. Tally your leaks for three days: what caused each one (sneeze, laugh, lift, urge). Mostly urge points to reason 6; mostly cough, sneeze or lift points to 1, 4 and 5.
  5. Set a date 8 weeks away to repeat the hold time and the tally. Fewer or smaller leaks and a longer hold mean it is working, even if you can't feel it.

When to get a person to check

See a doctor or a pelvic floor physical therapist if you can't feel the muscle after a week or two, if you have pain, a bulge or heaviness, blood in your urine, or leaks that began suddenly, or if you have trained properly for 3 months with no change. A physical therapist can check the squeeze in person, which is the one thing a guide cannot do.

Common questions

Why do I feel nothing when I squeeze?

Either you haven't found the muscle yet, or it is already tight, or it is tired. Try lying down with smaller squeezes, check with a hand on your belly, and if you can't feel a clear let-go either, practise relaxing first.

How do I know if my Kegels are working?

Measure instead of waiting for a feeling: your hold time, how many full squeezes you can do with a full let-go, and a three-day leak tally every two weeks.

How long should I do Kegels before giving up?

NICE asks for at least 3 months of a proper programme before judging it. If the squeeze is right and nothing has changed after that, see a physical therapist rather than doing more of the same.

Can Kegels make leaking worse?

A squeeze that pushes down instead of lifting can, and so can squeezing a pelvic floor that is already too tight. That is why checking the method comes first.

Do Kegels work for urge leaks?

Less directly. Bladder training is the first treatment for urge leaks, and for mixed leaks guidelines suggest treating the part that bothers you most first.

Where to start today

Do the 10-minute check above tonight. If you want to see in one minute why squeezing alone often doesn't fix leaks, take the free 1-minute check. For the other guides, see all our pelvic floor guides.

For what Kegels can and cannot do, see the benefits of Kegel exercises for women.

Sources: Bump R. et al., Assessment of Kegel pelvic muscle exercise performance after brief verbal instruction, Am J Obstet Gynecol, 1991. Thompson J. and O'Sullivan P., Levator plate movement during voluntary pelvic floor muscle contraction, Int Urogynecol J, 2003. Dumoulin C., Cacciari L., Hay-Smith J., Pelvic floor muscle training versus no treatment for urinary incontinence in women, Cochrane, 2018. NICE guideline NG123, Urinary incontinence and pelvic organ prolapse in women: management, 2019. Cleveland Clinic, Kegel exercises (my.clevelandclinic.org/health/articles/14611-kegel-exercises). Miller J., Ashton-Miller J., DeLancey J., A pelvic muscle precontraction can reduce cough-related urine loss in selected women with mild SUI, J Am Geriatr Soc, 1998. Adherence to pelvic floor muscle training in postmenopausal women, Climacteric, 2022. Fantl J. et al., Efficacy of bladder training in older women with urinary incontinence, JAMA, 1991. Training and education, not medical advice.